Supreme Court leans toward ending affirmative action in college admissions

Initiatives like direct admissions are about changing the narrative of a college education from one of scarcity to one of opportunity, by ensuring students know that college opportunity is an abundant resource — and one that’s available to them. “White supremacy continues to wield the model minority myth as a tool to divide people of color. In portraying affirmative action as a zero-sum game between Asian Americans and other minorities, Students for Fair Admissions is, once again, using Asian Americans to invalidate the struggles of other people of color. As Asian Americans, we must speak out against these narratives and call on our communities to do the same.

I came to Sasha worried about and frankly dumbfounded by the college admissions process. I was unsure what to write about and how to go about drafting the essay that perfectly captured my passion, interests, and self. From the beginning, Sasha amazed me with his understanding of the process, and ability to lend clarity and direction to me when I desperate needed it. While we do not know how far the supreme court will go in their ruling, many legal experts believe this could be the end of affirmative action as we know it, and the beginning of a new era in college admissions. The exact details of the ruling, and how colleges will react to it remain to be seen, but we do expect that this will change how students apply to colleges, and may impact overall college admissions strategy.

Suspected Cyberattack Closes Northern Essex Community College

Unfortunately that’s not the discussion taking place on those college campuses where there is concern about shortage of men. Those discussions focus on equality of result rather than equality of process. Tilting the scales to achieve gender balance, or to achieve any other particular end result, isn’t defensible and isn’t the answer. Back in 2006 Jennifer Delahunty, then the dean of admissions at Kenyon College, wrote an op-ed for The New York Times in which she argued that gender balance matters in ways large and small on a college campus.

  1. “Race, for some highly qualified applicants, can be the determinative factor just as being an oboe player in a year in which the Harvard-Radcliffe Orchestra needs an oboe player will be the tip.”
  2. This way we would not put one’s race above others like affirmative action rules.
  3. I am a firm believer in this concept, and I believe a man, or a woman is free to choose a path in their life that is both challenging and fulfilling.
  4. Several justifications were provided to support this affirmative action program.
  5. I had a very positive experience using this website, I will be a returning customer.
  6. A crowd of several hundred people gathered outside the Supreme Court more than hour before the arguments got underway – most of whom appeared to be in support of the universities.

Additionally, when we study the effects in states that have outlawed affirmative action, we find that, whatever the rhetoric, in reality the actual enrollment of minority students drops. At the University of Michigan, the evidence shows that the inability to consider race negatively affected student racial diversity despite a decade’s worth of race-neutral recruitment programs. In its amicus brief in the Fisher case, the university noted downward racial enrollment trends in the wake of 2007’s Proposition 2. While the language of “equal treatment” sounds fair, the effect of such supposedly “color-blind” practices how long is a essay paragraph in the college admissions context is the opposite of fair. In fact, when we fail to account for the differential experiences and varied contributions of applicants, we create a college environment that limits opportunity and impoverishes the learning environment for all students. I am not aware of other admissions formulas that give points based on gender, but at one time a number of colleges used formulas that gave points for racial or ethnic diversity. I remember one flagship public university using a ranking system for out-of-state applicants that involved a zero-to-two rating in seven categories.

What Is Affirmative Action in College Admissions?

The court determined no evident or essential connection between intellectual diversity and ethnic diversity (Kaplin & Lee, 2009). However, an appeals court overturned the verdict a year later, stating that the admissions criteria were lawful. In subsequent judgments, the Supreme Court has approved Bakke and re-sponsored specialized evaluation systems that include race among the many variables to foster inclusion in its judgments. In her complaint, Fisher alleged that the provision was discriminatory towards Caucasian students.

affirmative action college admissions essay

Jim is a past president of the National Association for College Admission Counseling. As a content writer for PrepScholar, Ashley is passionate about giving college-bound students the in-depth information they need to get into the school of their dreams. Our step-by-step guide to the college application process will teach you how. You can stay on top of what’s happening with affirmative action nationally and at individual colleges by doing some research. This means that whether you’re affected by affirmative action—and how you’re affected by it— depends on each university’s individual policies. As probably any student, I was quite hesitant about asking somebody else to do my assignments at first.

Using Discussions

One of the categories was “professional judgment,” designed to take into account other compelling circumstances of various types. A score of 10 on the 14-point scale would generally lead to admission, so receiving two points for professional judgment could tip the scales far more than the one point out of 100 BYU gave to men. Affirmative action is a set of legal procedures that aim to eliminate how to quote a website in an essay and make amends for past, present, and future unlawful discrimination. In general, affirmative action laws and policies try to ensure that applicants will not be rejected based on race, ethnicity, religion, nationality, age, gender, or disability. The concerns around affirmative action have consumed the modern world and have now instigated greater discussion than it was two decades ago.

Critics of affirmative action argue that it unfairly favors certain groups over others and is no longer necessary in today’s society (Garg et al., 261). However, given the continued disparities in education and employment opportunities, it is clear that affirmative action is still needed to ensure that all Americans have a chance to succeed. In conclusion, affirmative action in college admissions refers to giving preferential treatment to applicants who identify as members of groups that have been historically discriminated against, such as racial minorities or women. The rationale behind affirmative action is that it assists in flattening the playing field by providing opportunities to groups habitually understated in higher education. There is significant debate surrounding affirmative action in college admissions. Some argue that it is necessary to ensure equal opportunity, while others contend it is a form of reverse discrimination. The Supreme Court has ruled that affirmative action is constitutional but limits its use.

An Analysis of the Subject of Affirmative Action in College Admissions

It will also ensure that the ideal of affirmative action is implemented correctly, as it is unfair for admission officers to only operate behind closed doors. A major reason why affirmative action should be implemented in the college admission process is that it ensures a diverse environment. Diversity on college campuses is not only a means of increasing a university’s ranking and status but plays a major role in helping shape innovation. Learning with people from a wide range of backgrounds fosters collaboration and advancement which can benefit the students involved. Studies have shown the positive impacts that increased racial diversity brings, ranging from higher levels of academic success to the improvement of interpersonal relationships. Increased diversity on college campuses can also play a major role in influencing the United States’ status on the global stage. These benefits that affirmative action brings about may result in better economic outcomes and, among other payoffs, prepare students to work in a diverse global economy, increasing the productivity, effectiveness, and creativity of teams.

affirmative action college admissions essay

Extensive research supports their claims that students of color are more likely to face disciplinary action for the same behavior than their white counterparts. Researchers believe that the gap in the suspension rates of African American and white preschoolers is due to the teachers’ own latent biases . People with traditional names are also more unlikely to be contacted for a second interview. In recent years, the Supreme Court has frequently confirmed the legitimacy of race-conscious enrollment as a means of promoting inclusivity in postsecondary learning, despite challenges from the lower courts. For example, in 1995 and 1997, petitioners Gratz and Hamacher applied for acceptance to the University of Michigan. Even though the university deemed Gratz to be highly eligible and Hamacher to be in the qualifying category, they were refused early entry and subsequently denied admission to the program. Accordingly, they sued the university, arguing that race as a component of its admissions policy infringes the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

The Legal Confines of Affirmative action in Higher Education

Currently, Abigail Fisher is suing the University of Texas Austin for racism because she believes that she was rejected in 2008 due to her race. Her argument is that African American and Hispanic students with lower scores than her were accepted. She has been painted as a model student bridge in essay example who was made a victim by racial biases in this widely publicized case. The publicity she has drawn has led to negative beliefs that many minority people do not deserve their positions. It has only served to increase racial tensions that affirmative action wished to erase.

affirmative action college admissions essay

Supporters of affirmative action rally Monday in front of the Supreme Court. In the past, researchers have often classified Asian Americans under the same research roof and failed to account for the vast array of differences that exist between East and Southeast Asian Americans. The southeastern subgroup has been neglected for a long time because of their numbers, and therefore, the sample sizes are often too small. Please complete this reCAPTCHA to demonstrate that it’s you making the requests and not a robot.

Improving Recruitment and Support

A pending Supreme Court ruling on race-conscious admissions and other shifts like ChatGPT’s effects on application essays could upend the landscape. That race is intrinsic to a student’s experience, and that by excluding its consideration in admissions means that many aspects of a student may be disqualified from consideration. One is that gender research is a relatively young field, and up until 20 years essay on to kill a mocking bird ago most research into gender focused on women. The American Association of University Women report “How Schools Shortchange Girls” was based on two assumptions. The first was that if girls are being disadvantaged, then boys are obviously being advantaged. But today most research about education and gender suggests that the educational system disadvantages both girls and boys, but in different ways.

affirmative action college admissions essay

Affirmative action is all about increasing diversity in the workplace and on college campuses. The idea is to bring people with different ethnic, racial, and gender backgrounds together by giving them equal access. Which is open to minorities and non-minorities; most importantly it helps financially disadvantaged students .

Affirmative Action

Depending on the scope of the court’s ruling, the outcome could have profound implications beyond higher education – spilling over into workplace diversity programs and other efforts to confront longstanding discrimination. The universities say race is just one factor that is considered as part of broad individualized analysis of each applicant. Further allegations have arisen indicating that Harvard engages in racial biases by assigning essay on to kill a mocking bird Asian Americans specific ‘personal scores’ that are aimed at discrediting that particular applicant. The lawsuit indicates that Harvard employs certain quotas when it comes to admitting Asians as well as enforcing higher standards than for other people like White Americas. In certain universities, Asian students are demographically underrepresented which makes us question the true nature of diversity in our colleges and universities.

Schools that do use affirmative action can set their own policies as long as they don’t violate federal law. Many believe had it not been for affirmative action they would have never received the rights which this country promotes. This thinking of fairness and unfairness ties into the seeking of higher education where many students are pushed away because of their gender or skin color. Minorities who have never had a chance in being accepted into colleges, are now being accepted.

Deja un comentario